From the Founders II

Is the School Budget Equitable?



Surely, one of the most crucial and politically sensitive responsibilities of municipal government is the equitable delivery of quality education. Greenwich has had an excellent reputation in this regard, with neighborhood schools that have drawn many fine families to move here in spite of the lofty price of our real estate. In recent months, however, there have been questions about whether the division of our financial resources among our public schools is equitable, and whether or not taxpayers and parents in each of our districts are getting what they should for their money. According to one member of the Board of Education, these questions arise because of a lack of transparency in the BOE budget and a concerted effort on the part of school superintendent Betty Sternberg to allocate a disproportionate part of the overall budget to magnet schools.

Dr. Sternberg arrived on our doorstep fresh from her position as State Commissioner of Education in Hartford with a state mandate to create racial balance in our schools where called for, and a mission to achieve it by a discretionary application of the budget in favor of magnet schools. By creating a special curriculum with courses not available in other schools, she aims to encourage nonminority students to leave elementary schools in their neighborhoods to attend one of the two racially imbalanced schools, namely Hamilton Avenue and New Lebanon. This method of achieving the levels of racial balance specified in the Connecticut state statute is both costly and questionably effective or legal.

The State Department of Education has put a dozen towns on notice that they have racially imbalanced schools, in which minorities exceed by more than 25 percent their own percentage of the population in the district. Towns are ordered to take corrective action; yet, in view of the recent U.S. Supreme Court decisions in Seattle and Louisville prohibiting the use of race as criteria for placing students, there is a serious question whether the state statute is constitutional. Marianna Ponns Cohen, a newly elected member of the Board of Education and lawyer, with corporate as well as constitutional law experience, who voted against the board’s proposed budget, believes it is not likely to pass muster under the equal protection clause of our federal Constitution. While Connecticut’s racial balance statute has yet to be tested in court, one thing is clear — federal law preempts state law. Meanwhile, Attorney General Richard Blumenthal has studiously avoided issuing an interpretation as to whether the Connecticut racial balance statute was indeed rendered unconstitutional by the Supreme Court’s Seattle case. Ms. Cohen is further concerned that, under the very same Connecticut statute, by creating unequal educational opportunities within the school district and allocating inequitable and disproportionate funding for facilities not available to others, the town could become liable in suits based on equal opportunity.

To lend an aura of popular support for this program, Dr. Sternberg created the RISE committee whose members were asked to be available to meet several times over last summer to study and recommend ways to achieve racial balance and to address declining enrollment. But with an unpredicted increase in the student population, the latter was no longer a problem, and the sole issue became racial balancing. Since more than half of the committee members worked for or were connected in other ways with the superintendent, and a third of its members were not even residents of Greenwich, this committee could hardly be called representative. According to one member, after the first meeting in June, the next meeting was not until August when members were presented with a list of options to vote on — a list drawn up by the administration without consulting with the committee. The result was predetermined. It was virtually impossible to avoid choosing an option that didn’t involve magnet schools. A number of members representing the community at large were outraged by what they viewed as a rigged process.

Supporting magnet schools is all well and good as long as there is an equitable allocation of resources among all the schools as required by law (Section 10-220 of the Connecticut state statute). The Board of Education’s own figures for last year show that New Lebanon, for example, receives $14,370 per student while Riverside receives $7,688 — a two to one ratio. Part of the reason for this is that the student population of New Lebanon is half that of Riverside. Additional costs may also be justified based on need — teaching English as a second language (ESL) courses, for example. But what is not reflected in the magnet school numbers are the federal, state and private funds, including Title 1, which add well over one million dollars each to the budgets of the two current magnet schools plus New Lebanon, proposed to become another magnet. Title 1 is designed to make supplemental funds available to schools in low income areas with high needs assessments. Taking into account all supplemental federal, state and private funds, expenditures per student at New Lebanon increase to a conservatively estimated $21,000!

It should be noted that since taxpayer money is not involved, federal and state contributions need not be considered in presentations to the BET, but they clearly should be a factor in determining equitable allocation of resources within a district. Also questioned is whether significant shifts of money from the magnet school budgets into the BOE central office account was appropriate, and whether this was due to a desire to lessen the reported funding of the magnet schools.

A lawyer hired by the BOE has offered an opinion that superintendents have a degree of latitude in determining what is “equitable.” Betty Sternberg has made a determined effort to make this latitude as broad as possible. However, she is an unelected official, and there should be reasonable limits to this power. This is especially important when said official has demonstrated an open antagonism toward those town residents who happen not to agree with her philosophy.

At the heart of the matter is the threat that many of our neighborhood schools are coming out second best under a program that greatly favors a select few schools and programs. While Betty Sternberg no doubt believes in the sanctity of her mission, we believe she has lost sight of what is fair for the rest of the student population. She provided no evidence to her RISE committee, for example, that increasing the racial mix in schools raises the overall academic performance of the student body. Interestingly, there is also opposition to Dr. Sternberg’s programs from minority families that want to keep their children in their own familiar neighborhoods. When presenting her program to a Hispanic audience at New Lebanon school, one member listened patiently for some time, then was heard to say, “Oh, we get it! You don’t want us here!”

We believe the BOE should first wait for the courts to decide whether the state statute is constitutional and meanwhile concentrate its efforts and money on improving the educational process in all our schools and meet the needs of all our children so that we don’t end up with a two-class educational system.

 

Greenwich Agenda

  • The Many Faces of Multi Media

    2014.09.20
     @ Meli-Melo of Greenwich

    Dr. Julia Trebing, Director Creative Therapies in Stamford, CT exhibits her paintings at Meli-Melo Creperie & Juice Bar  during Sept...

  • Nigh Season: New Paintings By David Konigsberg

    2014.09.13
     @ Kenise Barnes Fine Art

    Dates: September 13 – October 31, 2014 Opening Reception: September 13, 6 – 8:30 PM  Public Invited   NIGH...

  • Undulate: Paintings By Julie Gross and Margaret Neill

    2014.09.13
     @ Kenise Barnes Fine Art

    GALLERY II Dates: September 13 – October 31, 2014 Opening Reception: September 13, 6 – 8:30 PM Public Invited...

  • Breast Cancer Alliance's Go For Pink Shopping Event

    2014.10.02
     @ Greenwich Avenue area

    Breast Cancer Alliance announced that it is partnering with Greenwich merchants for a special day of events and shopping on Thursday, October 2nd...

  • New Goergen Lecture

    2014.10.02
     @ Bruce Museum

    Reflections on Highlights of the Hohenbuchau Collection featuring Peter C. Sutton Known today as the "Golden Age" of Netherlandish...

  • Parties at the JCC Center

    2014.09.02
     @ Stamford JCC

    A place to celebrate birthdays and special occasions. Be a guest at your own party! The JCC offers a wonderful space for you and your guests to...

  • SPLURGE Matches Scarf Donations for Cancer Patients

    2014.10.01
     @ SPLURGE

    SPLURGE and the Cancer Institute at Greenwich Hospital are partnering to bring comfort and encouragement to cancer patients.  From October...

  • Laurel House Family Seminar Series

    2014.09.18
     @ Laurel House

    Thursday evenings, September 18, October 2, 16, 30, 6:30-8:00 pm Join us Thursday evenings for this four part Family Seminar Series as...

  • Muddy Up 5k Adventure Run & Family Fun Walk

    2014.10.05
     @ Camp Simmons

    Are you ready for some MUDDY fun? Boys & Girls Club of Greenwich is proud to host the 3rd annual Muddy Up 5k Adventure Run & Family Fun...

  • Muddy Up 5k & Family Fun Walk

    2014.10.05
     @ Camp Simmons

    Race starts at 9:15 a.m. REGISTRATION HAS BEEN EXTENDED TO MON. SEPT. 29 at 8:00 A.M. DON'T LIKE THE MUD? SPONSOR A CLUB MEMBER TO RUN...

  • Sweat for a Cause

    2014.10.05
     @ SoulCycle Greenwich

    The Young Women's League of New Canaan (YWL) is sponsoring its first fundraiser of the season, "Sweat For A Cause" at SoulCycle...

  • SM&NC Farm Market

    2014.06.15
     @ Stamford Museum & Nature Center

    Sundays, June 15 – October 5, 10am – 2pm We're thrilled to bring back the SM&NC Farm Market — now on Sundays!...

  • Tuesday Toddler Tours

    2014.10.07
     @ Bruce Museum

    Come to the Bruce this fall to take part in our exciting new children and family programming! No advance registration is required and programs...

  • Flower Power

    2014.10.08
     @ SM Home Gallery

    SM Home Gallery show featuring two Greenwich based artists: Margaret Bragg and Penny Putnam. The art show runs thorough November 22nd....

  • Lyme Research Alliance 3rd Annual Golf Tournament

    2014.10.09
     @ The Stanwich Club

    Tee up and raise funds & awareness for Lyme disease awareness at one of the area’s finest golf courses. The golf tournament is part of...

  • Exhibit Ira BARKOFF

    2014.10.11
     @ Canfin Gallery

    “The beauty of the physical world becomes a metaphor for the capacity of the spirit to reveal itself". Ira Barkoff Evocation of...

  • Annual Outdoor Arts Festival

    2014.10.11
     @ Bruce Museum

    There is plenty to discover on Columbus Day weekend, and this year much of it will be in Greenwich, on the grounds of the Bruce Museum.  On...

  • Outdoor Arts Festival

    2014.10.11
     @ Bruce Museum

    Come and enjoy the Bruce Museum’s 33rd Annual Outdoor Arts Festival. More than 85 artists from all over the country, many of them new to...

  • Lookbook Live Tour

    2014.10.12
     @ Westchester Mall

    In September + October 2014, Simon will team up with three of the world's top fashion magazines, Glamour, GQ, and  Vogue on a nationwide...


Show More...

Most Popular Articles

  1. Moroccan Nights
    Boys & Girls Club of Greenwich
  2. Into The Woods
    Bruce Museum's 27th Annual Renaissance Ball
  3. American Gold Cup
    North Salem, NY
  4. Greenwich Fashion Day Out
    Greenwich Avenue
  5. 5 Key Pieces To Buy Now
    Buy now and wear all season