For the Record

Fighting the FAA



Bob Capazzo

The relatively short distance to New York airports is often referred to in promotional literature extolling the virtues of living in Greenwich. Not mentioned is the price many of us pay for this convenience. Air traffic has expanded dramatically, especially at Westchester County Airport where general aviation has grown at an even faster pace than commercial airline traffic. All this new air traffic brings with it the substantial increase in noise level we experience with ever-greater frequency over our heads. Since New York airports are not just a destination but a major hub for both domestic and international flights, increased traffic has given them the distinction of leading the nation in delayed departures and landings. Kennedy, LaGuardia and Newark are at the bottom of the list of all U.S. airports for on-time landings. And when landings are delayed, so are departures, creating a ripple effect throughout the country. This has led the FAA to undertake the restructuring and broadening of its approach and departure flight patterns in New York air space.

The proposed changes have stirred up a beehive of complaints from residents of towns throughout lower Fairfield County, especially New Canaan, Wilton and Weston where residents anticipate more frequent high-decibel disturbance of the peace and tranquility of their patios and gardens. Eleven towns, including Greenwich, have banded together to sue the FAA, and at the behest of Attorney General Richard Blumenthal, have been joined by the state. The suit is based on the failure of the FAA to follow proper procedure in providing public notice and meetings, as well as failure to factor in environmental issues.

Bruce Dixon, chairman of the Selectmen’s Committee on Aircraft Noise, is a licensed pilot. He and Selectman Peter Crumbine have studied the material in the FAA proposal at length and have found its presentation of the proposed new flight routes extremely complex and difficult to analyze. Lacking specifications on altitude, it is also incomplete. Without altitude information — suspected by some to be a deliberate omission — there is no way to determine potential noise levels.

The FAA study supporting the agency’s proposed changes was also faulted for not incorporating data on private aviation with its burgeoning number of light jets. The unpredictable schedules of general aviation flights make them less subject to analysis than scheduled airlines, but their effect on flight control operations can be significant. According to Bruce Dixon, controllers, for example, must allow a distance of two miles between heavy jets when landing or taking off in order to avoid the tornado effect from the lead plane’s engines. For a light jet following a heavy, they must allow as much as five miles’ separation to avoid turbulence.

If the FAA’s revised flight patterns promised important time savings and a significant increase in on-time landings, they might be worth the greater noise pollution of our neighborhoods. The FAA’s claim of shaving six minutes off each late arrival has been seriously challenged by consultants hired by the communities; this is clearly only a partial solution at best. One problem, according to those knowledgeable about the airline industry, is our half-century-old, radar-based air traffic control system. An investment in a GPS-based system, while calculated to be around $15 billion, would allow planes to fly closer together and fly more direct routes rather than vectoring all over the sky — thereby saving precious fuel.

Still, all of the above may not solve the air traffic crunch at the airports. There are just too many planes trying to take off and land at the same time. Proposals have been floated to lower the cap on the number of planes per day, or to hike landing fees and charge airlines a premium for those popular morning and late afternoon hours when air traffic peaks. The most meaningful solution, at least ten years over the horizon, is a fourth airport. The Port Authority has taken control and is developing Stewart International Airport just sixty-five miles north of Manhattan. Rail service to Manhattan is being contemplated.

Meanwhile, chances are slim that the towns or the state will actually win a suit against the FAA. No one ever has. So why are we joining other towns in this action if we’re just tilting at windmills? The simple answer is to put pants on our complaints about the FAA establishing new flight patterns without regard to those who live under them. Partly it’s to be a good neighbor to other towns with the same concerns, and partly it’s to give concrete support to the state in its case against the FAA.

Nor are Fairfield County towns alone in this. Legal action against the FAA has been initiated by a number of New Jersey communities as well. In sharing the cost with others, we are able to hire expert legal council and a lobbyist that specialize in this type of litigation, plus a grassroots publicist. The cost of joining in the litigation is relatively modest, and we will be putting pressure on the FAA to respond positively to our concerns. To succeed, says Chris Shays, it’s going to take everyone at the local state and federal level working together. At the very least, it will be a delaying action while more palatable and effective solutions can be developed. 

 

Greenwich Agenda

  • Harvest Fair and Gift Show

    2014.11.01
     @ Second Congregational Church

    Event Will Include Hay Mazes, Games, Crafts, Food, Holiday Shopping The community is invited to a Harvest Fair and Gift Show on Saturday, Nov....

  • New Fitness Class: SalsaTone

    2014.11.01
     @ Latin Moves Dance Studio

    Starting November 1st ~ Every Saturday morning 10 to 11 AM Instructor: Melissa Lopez Start your weekend off right with this exciting cardio...

  • Exhibit Ira BARKOFF

    2014.10.11
     @ Canfin Gallery

    “The beauty of the physical world becomes a metaphor for the capacity of the spirit to reveal itself". Ira Barkoff Evocation of...

  • Parties at the JCC Center

    2014.09.02
     @ Stamford JCC

    A place to celebrate birthdays and special occasions. Be a guest at your own party! The JCC offers a wonderful space for you and your guests to...

  • Flinn Gallery Art Opening

    2014.10.30
     @ Flinn Gallery 2nd floor

    FLINN GALLERY Opening Reception 'IN FOCUS' Thursday October 30, 6 - 8pm Seven artists share their visions - Carolyn Conrad,...

  • IMAGINE CANDY- SWEET TASTINGS!!!

    2014.10.24
     @ Imagine Candy

    Imagine Candy located in Scarsdale Village- Winner of 2014 Best West of Westchester by Westchester Magazine- holds a Belgian Chocolate and Candy...

  • Flower Power

    2014.10.08
     @ SM Home Gallery

    SM Home Gallery show featuring two Greenwich based artists: Margaret Bragg and Penny Putnam. The art show runs thorough November 22nd....

  • Lynne Scalo Design Opening

    2014.11.05

    Please join Lynne Scalo, Greenwich Magazine and athome Magazine to celebrate the Greenwich showroom opening of Lynne Scalo Design Cocktails...

  • Breast Cancer Alliance Benefit Luncheon & Fashion Show

    2014.11.06
     @ Hyatt Regency Greenwich

    Breast Cancer Alliance to Host Branching Out, Coming Together, Aspiring to a Cure 19th Annual Benefit Luncheon & Fashion Show: November 6,...

  • Free Screening of Documentary ' Children of the Inquisition'

    2014.11.06
     @ Bush-Holley House

    Join filmmaker Joseph Lovett as he presents his documentary film and multi-platform project of personal exploration and...

  • P.A.L.S. 2nd Annual Soarin' Soiree~ November 7, 2014

    2014.11.07
     @ Greenwich Country Club

    You are invited to join our State Senator, L. Scott Frantz and our First Selectman, Peter J. Tesei, for an awe-inspiring evening to benefit Patient...

  • John Hardy Event

    2014.11.08
     @ Bloomingdale's

    John Hardy One of a kind. One at a time. Each by hand. Bloomingdale's is inviting YOU to meet the head designer Guy Bedarida as he presents...

  • Olivine Gabbro Opening

    2014.11.08

    Olivine Gabbro invites you to join them for their Opening Party! DJ | Cocktails | H'Orderves | Gift Bags Made to Measure Beautifully...

  • Meet Joshua Safran, Author of "Free Spirit: Growing Up On the Road and Off the Grid"

    2014.11.11
     @ YWCA Greenwich

    Meet the author of this powerful memoir. Joshua Safran is an author, attorney, occasional rabbi, and nationally recognized advocate for...

  • Markham Roberts: Decorating the Way I See It

    2014.11.13
     @ Belle Haven Club

    Join us as Interior Designer Markham Roberts shares coveted design insights, key to creating the perfect home. The program will include...

  • AGAPANTHUS RISING

    2014.11.18
     @ Greenwich Water Club

    Like the Agapanthus flower, which starts as just a seed, we all have something to share with the world.  Sadly, we don't always nurture...

  • The Enchanted Forest

    2014.11.21
     @ Hyatt Regency Greenwich

    Junior League of Greenwich presents 2014 Enchanted Forest! Holiday Boutiques Gingerbeard Workshops Santa's Breakfast...

  • Junior League of Greenwich The Enchanted Forest

    2014.11.21
     @ Junior League of Greenwich

    The Junior League of Greenwich (JLG) will host its annual holiday fundraiser, The Enchanted Forest on Friday, November 21 through Sunday, November...


Show More...

Most Popular Articles

  1. Go For Pink
    Greenwich Avenue
  2. 100th Annual Hunt Ball
    Conyers Farm
  3. 6 Ways to Practice Mindfulness
    Simple steps to get the most out of each moment
  4. SoundWaters Tall Ships Ball
    Stamford Yacht Club
  5. 10 Things To Do This Fall in Greenwich
    Greenwich offers endless opportunities to take advantage of during this season.